Skip to main content

Cocktails

Now this is not meant to be an expansive list of cocktails or some fancy bar thing. We simply use cocktails in our reviews, and just in-case someone comes up and is like What’s a Godfather? What’s in that? They can have it nicely linked for them to peruse.
Now this is not meant to be an expansive list of cocktails or some fancy bar thing. We simply use cocktails in our reviews, and just in-case someone comes up and is like What’s a Godfather? What’s in that? They can have it nicely linked for them to peruse. We’ve rated each cocktail against like spirits, and overall. However these are more preferences than hard and fast rules.

No Buffalo Spirit Guide

  1. Pour 151 into Shot Glass
  2. Top with Moxie
  3. Complain about battery acid
Spirit Rating:
5/10

Overall Rating:
3/10

No Buffalo Spirit Guide

  • 4 Parts Bakon Vodka
  • 1 Part Maple Syrup (Get the real stuff)
  1. Pour Bakon Vodka into shot glass
  2. Add Maple Syrup in a clockwise motion.
Spirit Rating:
7/10

Overall Rating:
4/10

No Buffalo Spirit Guide

  • 1 Part Bakon Vodka
  • 2 Parts Orange Juice

  • Garnish: Strip of Bacon
  1. Pour ingredients over ice
  2. Stir and Garnish w/ Bacon strip
  3. Breakfast
Spirit Rating:
8/10

Overall Rating:
6/10

No Buffalo Spirit Guide

  1. Pour into shaker with ice
  2. Strain into shot glasses.
Spirit Rating:
3/10

Overall Rating:
2/10

No Buffalo Spirit Guide

  • 2 Parts Brandy
  • 1 Part Cointreau
  • 1 Part Lemon Juice

  • Garnish: Lemon Rind
  1. Mix all parts in shaker w/ ice
  2. Strain into glass.
  3. Garnish
Spirit Rating:
5/10

Overall Rating:
2/10

No Buffalo Spirit Guide

  • 3 Parts Brandy
  • 2 Parts Gin
  • 1 Dash Dry Vermouth

  • Garnish: Lemon Peel
  1. Mix all parts in shaker w/ ice
  2. Strain into glass.
  3. Garnish
Spirit Rating:
5/10

Overall Rating:
2/10

No Buffalo Spirit Guide

  • 3 Parts 151 Rum
  • 1 Part Tabasco/Sriracha Sauce
  1. Pour Rum into Shot glass
  2. Add sauce
  3. Enjoy pain
Spirit Rating:
6/10

Overall Rating:
4/10

No Buffalo Spirit Guide

  • 1 Part Rum
  • 3 Parts Ginger Beer

  • Garnish: Lime Wedge
  1. Mix all parts in glass w/ ice
  2. Stir and Garnish
Spirit Rating:
5/10

Overall Rating:
5/10

Buffalo Spirit Guide

  • 1 Part Gin
  • 1 Part Tonic

  • Garnish: Lime Wedge
  1. Mix all parts in glass w/ ice
  2. Stir and Garnish
Spirit Rating:
9/10

Overall Rating:
8/10

No Buffalo Spirit Guide

  • 1 Part Scotch
  • 1 Part Amaretto
  1. Mix all parts in glass w/ ice
  2. Enjoy
Spirit Rating:
9/10

Overall Rating:
8/10

No Buffalo Spirit Guide

  • 12 Parts Gin
  • 1 Part Dry Vermouth

  • Garnish: Olive w/ Toothpick
  1. STIR all parts in shaker w/ ice
  2. Strain into glass.
  3. Garnish
Spirit Rating:
8/10

Overall Rating:
8/10

No Buffalo Spirit Guide

  • 12 Parts Bourbon or Rye Whiskey
  • 1 Sugar Cube or 1 Part Simple Syrup
  • 2-3 Dashes of Angostura Bitters

  • Garnish: Cherries and Orange Wedge
  1. Add sugar/syrup and dash with bitters.
  2. Add crushed ice about half the glass, add half the spirit and stir
  3. Add the remaining crushed ice and spirit and stir
  4. Garnish with Cherry and Orange Wedge as desired.
Spirit Rating:
8/10

Overall Rating:
8/10

No Buffalo Spirit Guide

  1. Follow this helpful guide replacing Disaronno with desired spirit.
Spirit Rating:
10/10

Overall Rating:
9/10

No Buffalo Spirit Guide

  • 4 Parts Gin
  • 6 Parts Orange Juice
  • 1 Grenadine
  1. Mix all parts in glass w/ ice
Spirit Rating:
8/10

Overall Rating:
7/10

No Buffalo Spirit Guide

  • 4 Parts White Rum
  • 6 Parts Orange Juice
  • 1 Grenadine

  • Garnish: Knife
  1. Mix all parts in shaker w/ ice
  2. Strain into glass, pretending it’s an elevator.
  3. Garnish
Spirit Rating:
7/10

Overall Rating:
6/10

No Buffalo Spirit Guide

  • 2 Parts Rum
  • 5 Parts Coke

  • Garnish: A lime wedge you throw back because this isn’t a Cuba Libre
  1. Mix all parts in glass w/ ice
  2. Act boring
Spirit Rating:
5/10

Overall Rating:
5/10

No Buffalo Spirit Guide

  • 2 Parts White Rum
  • 5 Parts Throwback Pepsi
  1. Mix all parts in glass w/ ice
Spirit Rating:
8/10

Overall Rating:
7/10

Buffalo Spirit Guide

  • 8 Parts Blended Scotch
  • 3 Parts Drambuie

  • Garnish: A rust-covered nail
  1. Mix all parts in glass w/ ice
  2. Stir and Garnish
Spirit Rating:
10/10

Overall Rating:
9/10

No Buffalo Spirit Guide

  • 2 Parts Vodka
  • 3 Parts Orange Juice
  1. Mix all parts in glass w/ ice
Spirit Rating:
8/10

Overall Rating:
8/10

No Buffalo Spirit Guide

  • 1 Part Kellan or equally terrible whiskey
  • 4 Parts Irish Cream
  • 1 Part Melon Liquer

  • Garnish: THING
  1. Mix all parts in shaker w/ ice
  2. Strain into shot glass.
Spirit Rating:
3/10

Overall Rating:
1/10

No Buffalo Spirit Guide

  1. Mix all parts in shaker w/ ice
  2. Strain and serve in sugar-rimmed glass
  3. Garnish
Spirit Rating:
7/10

Overall Rating:
7/10

No Buffalo Spirit Guide

  • All Parts Tequila
  • Salt
  • Lemon Wedge
  1. Pour Tequila into shot glass
  2. Sprinkle salt on back of hand
  3. Lick salt, down shot, suck on lemon wedge
Spirit Rating:
8/10

Overall Rating:
7/10

No Buffalo Spirit Guide

  • 3 Parts Tequila
  • 6 Parts Orange Juice
  • 1 Parts Grenadine

  • Tiny Umbrella
  1. Mix tequila and orange juice in glass w/ ice
  2. Pour Grenadine over bar spoon.
  3. Garnish
Spirit Rating:
8/10

Overall Rating:
7/10

No Buffalo Spirit Guide

  • 3 Parts Gin
  • 2 Parts Lemon Juice
  • 1 Parts Simple Syrup
  • 4 Parts Carbonated Water

  • Garnish: Cherry
  1. Mix gin, juice, and syrup into glass w/ ice
  2. Top off with Carbonated Water
  3. Garnish
Spirit Rating:
6/10

Overall Rating:
5/10

No Buffalo Spirit Guide

  • 12 Parts Vodka
  • 1 Part Dry Vermouth

  • Garnish: Olive
  1. SHAKE all parts in shaker w/ ice
  2. Strain into glass.
  3. Garnish
Spirit Rating:
6/10

Overall Rating:
5/10

No Buffalo Spirit Guide

  • 1 Part Vodka
  • 1 Part Tonic

  • Garnish: Lime Wedge
  1. Mix all parts in glass w/ ice
  2. Stir and Garnish
Spirit Rating:
6/10

Overall Rating:
6/10

No Buffalo Spirit Guide

  1. Mix all parts in glass w/ ice
Spirit Rating:
5/10

Overall Rating:
5/10

No Buffalo Spirit Guide

  • 2 Parts Whiskey
  • 3 Parts Ginger Ale

  • Garnish: Lime Wedge
  1. Mix all parts in glass w/ ice
  2. Garnish
Spirit Rating:
7/10

Overall Rating:
7/10

No Buffalo Spirit Guide

  • 3 Parts Whiskey
  • 1 Part Simple Syrup
  • 2 Parts Lemon Juice
  • 1 Part Egg White

  • Garnish: Lemon Rind
  1. Mix all parts in shaker w/ ice
  2. Strain into glass.
  3. Garnish
Spirit Rating:
8/10

Overall Rating:
7/10

No Buffalo Spirit Guide

  • 5 Parts Vodka
  • 3 Parts Kahlua or Kamora
  • 2 Parts Light Cream (Or Milk)

  • Garnish: A rug that pulls the room together
  1. Mix all parts in shaker w/ ice
  2. Strain into glass.
  3. Garnish
Spirit Rating:
10/10

Overall Rating:
9/10