Well then I think it’s about time we seriously started moving into reviewing the previously untapped market for us – namely tequilas that are not silver. In order to ease this more than previous attempts – we decided to grab the reposado of a silver that we actually like.
Sadly though it appears that once again stepping outside of our comfort zone (it’s scotch, scotch is our comfort zone – not that we are particularly better at reviewing it, but we are very comfortable) – we get our heads bitten off. Although I suppose it could have been much worse.
What they Say: “” (They say nothing)
Taste: 6.0 – It starts off with that sweetness you get from the aroma.
Aftertaste: 4.0 – Sadly it does not follow with the mellowing flavors. In a way it almost combines with the burn to produce something not likable at all.
Burn/Smooth: 3.0 – This is not smooth, which is sad.
Aroma: 7.0 –It’s got that sweet agave but it’s mellowed out by other flavors, and actually is quite nice if just a little too sugary smelling.
Manliness: 7.0 – While I do like the lack of wank and the cut of the bottle, I also have to give it manliness points for being a Reposado tequila that burns like a tequila. I know this seems odd, but with tequila it’s manly if it’s bad, or SUPER good, but anywhere in between isn’t manly – and silvers tend to get less manly as well.
Tequila and Lime: 6.0 – The addition of salt and lime does improve that aftertaste if I’m quick enough.
Tequila Sunrise: 5.5 – Makes an okay sunrise.
Value: 6.0 – While that isn’t bad value, not sure if I wouldn’t grab something else.
Google Shop Average: $20
Metric Score: 38.75/70 |+| Metric Average: 5.54 |+| Reviewer Average: 5.5
Final Thoughts: Get the silver, although possibly the anejo is just really good, perhaps one day we’ll find out.
Top Posts & Pages
- Kamchatka Vodka 750mL
- 1800 Silver Tequila 750mL
- Russian Standard Platinum Vodka 750mL
- E & J XO Extra Smooth Brandy 750mL
- Familia Camarena Silver Tequila 750mL
- SCIENCE TIME - Kahlua vs. Kamora
- Seagram’s Extra Dry Gin 750mL
- E & J VSOP Brandy Superior Reserve 750mL
- Hammer + Sickle 750mL
- Olmeca Altos Reposado Tequila
Tags2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 Ale Allagash Argentina Australia Beer Poster Challenge Berkshire Brewing Company Blended Scotch Bourbon Cabernet Sauvignon California Chile France Gin Italy Lager Malbec Merlot Napa Valley On the Rocks Pinot Noir Portugal Rum Scotch Silver Tequila Single Malt Sonoma County Spain Stout Syrah Tequila Vodka Washington State Weekly Wine Whiskey White Russian Zinfandel