Back to ‘scotch’ instead of tequila we instead take a slight diversion to Japan. We’ve actually had some pretty good luck with Japanese whiskies in the past, and though this looked to be one of the cheaper entry-level products hopes were high it could compete with it’s brothers the Yamazaki and the Hakushu.
While this makes a nice rocks glass whisky to enjoy, it is by no means an overall great product. This feels like a complete mess in a way almost tonally by smelling like a Lowland, tasting more like a Spey/Highland, and then burning like a bourbon. Much like the problem we’re having with the Sangre tequila’s this is very pretty to look at (of the other 2 this is by far better). I just wish this kept a theme and stuck too that.
What they Say: “From the house of Suntory Whisky Established 1923”
Taste: 5.5 – You get a whiff of that fruit and lightness but it’s already coupled with smoke and power. However the burn quickly makes your enjoyment diminish.
Aftertaste: 5.0 – There’s complexity here, but it’s certainly not as refined as other Japanese whiskies this site has reviewed. It may smell like a lowland, but the taste is more highland.
Burn/Smooth: 3.0 – Oh that burns like it came from Kentucky. It doesn’t also give you a nice warm feeling either.
Aroma: 7.0 – It smells like a lowland scotch, which is actually some good praise here. There’s a bit of fruit, some decent smoke but it’s light and nice. It smells delicious.
Manliness: 8.5 – So the text is bare-bones, but the bottle, the lettering, and color palate is on point. This is a beautiful bottle to own, and even the sealed foil is a unique material that adds class to this. Add the power of aftertaste here and no part of this is unmanly.
W/ Rocks: 6.0 – It takes some off the edge of that burn. However it’s not doing enough to make this a much better whisky to drink. It takes away the power instead of opening the whisky, it either needed to purely just remove burn, or dynamically change the whisky.
Value: 3.5 – This was bought for 3 dollars less, but the truth is inescapable. There are better whiskies at this price point, and despite how nice this smells like a scotch, and how beautiful it is in your bar – it’s just not good enough. There are better Japanese whiskies, and better scotches at or near this price.
Google Shop Average: $43
Metric Score: 38.5/70 |+| Metric Average: 5.5 |+| Reviewer Average: 4.0
Final Thoughts: The problem here is that I will always take the Yamazaki over this at the price it’s at. Even if this is more entry-level like compared to other Japanese whiskies it should have come down in price nearly a 1/4 to compete fully. I know metrically it may score high due to the aroma and manliness, but the taste and overall lack of value brings this down subjectively.
Top Posts & Pages
- Kamchatka Vodka 750mL
- 1800 Silver Tequila 750mL
- Russian Standard Platinum Vodka 750mL
- E & J XO Extra Smooth Brandy 750mL
- E & J VSOP Brandy Superior Reserve 750mL
- Hammer + Sickle 750mL
- Gray's Peak Small Batch Vodka 750mL
- Blanton's The Original Single Barrel Bourbon Whiskey 750mL
- Johnnie Walker Blue Label Scotch 750mL
- SCIENCE TIME - Kahlua vs. Kamora
Tags2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 Ale Allagash Argentina Australia Beer Poster Challenge Berkshire Brewing Company Blended Scotch Bourbon Cabernet Sauvignon California Chile France Gin Italy Lager Malbec Merlot Napa Valley On the Rocks Pinot Noir Portugal Rum Scotch Silver Tequila Single Malt Sonoma County Spain Stout Syrah Tequila Vodka Washington State Weekly Wine Whiskey White Russian Zinfandel